Gas or Electric Range? Which is Better for You?

Maybe you’re sitting in your kitchen – contemplating life and maybe also the difference between electric and gas ranges. Is there a difference? Which type is better?

When an appliance, stove, or range has reached the end of its life, you’re usually confined to purchasing and replacing the appliance with one that runs on the same fuel source. Through the popularity of social media and cooking shows, many amateur cooks seem to prefer to cook with gas.  However, not everyone has gas service to their home.

The fact is that only approximately half of American homes have gas service. The rest of us have to rely on electric. But even though gas is touted as practically a kitchen miracle worker, does gas really deliver on the hype? Does cooking with gas really outperform cooking with electric? Let’s take a closer look.

Gas or Electric Range? Which is Better for You?

Gas vs Electric Ranges in Cooking Tests

Instead of determining how well a stove or range could cook from its fuel source, appliance experts say consumers can find excellent choices in both gas and electric models.  “…without natural gas service, your culinary ambitions won’t be limited by the type of range you own,” Consumer Reports says.

For instance, one misconception says that gas ranges bring to a boil faster than electric ranges. This isn’t entirely true. Some things to consider include what type of electric range you’re cooking with and what exactly is being boiled. In one study, more electric smoothtop or radiant ranges fared better than gas ranges in both the High Heat and Simmering tests. In fact, approximately 65 percent of electric smoothtop ranges scored better over gas ranges for fast high heat boiling. However, in the Baking Test, almost two-thirds of tested gas models scored much better than electric ones. One of the largest discrepancies in range performance happened at the level of broiling.  The results were not what you might think!

In broil tests, less than 20% of gas ranges scored well. By contrast, 61% of electric ovens scored in Excellent or Very Good.

Which Type of Kitchen Range is Better for You?

After looking over the results from cooking tests between gas and electrics stoves and ranges, electric ranges seem to outperform where gas models rarely met the tests with any gusto. But, as they say, there are exceptions to every rule. That is the case here. What we’ve found is that there are many models of both gas and electric ranges that perform extremely well regardless of fuel source.

If you were feeling down because you were limited to an electric kitchen range, we feel optimistic these results should give consumers hope. Also, depending on your cooking style and methods of cooking, you might want to do a bit more research on which type of kitchen range would work best for you.